It was April of 2019, and I was aimlessly scrolling through my Instagram feed like any other day. However, one post made me stop: an announcement from Mindy Kaling that she was conducting the search for a South Asian teenage girl to star in her upcoming Netflix series. I screenshotted the announcement and promptly forwarded it to multiple of my friends who checked these boxes, hoping that they would share my enthusiasm! Just to be clear, I had no intention of trying to snag this role, but I did have an affinity for 20 minute comedy sitcoms and was a fan of Kaling from her work as a writer and actor on one of these very shows, The Office. Most importantly, I was delighted at the possibility of seeing myself represented on screen as the main character, rather than the usual diverse but inconsequential sidekick.
A year later in 2020, as I adjusted to online school and the many changes suddenly happening, I was happier than ever that Kaling’s project, now titled Never Have I Ever, was soon approaching and had just released a trailer. To my dismay, my enthusiasm waned as I watched the trailer. I thought the jokes were cringey, and was disappointed that the show did not seem to be the humorous and insightful commentary about being a brown teenager in America that I had hoped for.
After watching the whole series, I realized that the trailer is not a good representation of Never Have I Ever, but most importantly, I had unfair expectations for Kaling to begin with. She is one of the only mainstream female Indian-American producers in Hollywood, so I had unwittingly put increased pressure on her to sum up my entire cultural experience in one neat package with her new show. Everyone else in the Indian community wanted the same thing, though they all had different stories. This meant that Kaling had the burden of representing the entirety of the vast South Asian diaspora with her work, even though she should be allowed to tell whatever stories she wants to tell, shouldn’t she? In an interview with the New York Times, Kaling sums it up by saying,“[t]hose people who watch the show, particularly young Indian-American women, are the people that I want to like it the most. And they’re the ones that are going to be the toughest on me.”
This being said, as a “young Indian-American [woman]” myself, Never Have I Ever and its lead character Devi Vishwakumar (portrayed by Maitreyi Ramakrishnan) brought me joy. Devi is funny, bold, and unapologetic (sometimes to a fault). I was glad to see a realistic balance with how much Devi’s ethnicity informed her character. Devi’s race is neither blatantly ignored nor is it her sole defining trait. I would even argue that Devi’s experience as part of the Indian diaspora is not the most poignant part of the show, rather it is her experience with grief and trauma.
Devi, who is not shy but is nonetheless viewed as a “nerd” at school, is on a mission to reinvent herself in tenth grade. Though it is not uncommon to treat the new school year as a fresh start, Devi is fueled by the desire to return to equilibrium after catastrophe. Devi’s father died unexpectedly of a heart attack during her school orchestra concert the past year. As a psychosomatic response to this trauma, Devi became temporarily paralyzed and was confined to a wheelchair for the rest of her freshman year and summer, enduring taunts from insensitive classmates about her “fake” paralysis. Once Devi regains her ability to walk, which the show offers little explanation for, she is on a mission to move past loss by reinventing herself in the classic teen romcom fashion. She wears cute outfits, gets invited to parties with alcohol and (sort of) goes out with the most popular guy at school. Devi does all these things at the high cost of neglecting and eventually losing her best friends, but she still finds herself suffering from the unresolved trauma of her father’s death. Never Have I Ever takes the tropes of high school drama and uses them a vehicle to explore grief. However, the show’s serious subject matter did not bar it from being funny and light-hearted. The series is narrated by temperamental tennis legend John McEnroe, which seems like a strange choice but is eventually explained. Contrary to my expectations, McEnroe’s narration did not come off as condescending and I appreciated this unique element of the show.
Our protagonist, Devi, has a short fuse and wit which get her into sticky, albeit hilarious situations. My personal favorite is when she starts World War III at a Model United Nations conference to get back at her enemy, Ben Gross, portrayed by Jaren Lewison. I will admit that some of Devi’s questionable decisions made me cringe, but only because the show had roped me into caring about this realistically flawed, but fundamentally good character. Even though our stories are different, I felt emboldened seeing a chaotic, funny, and smart teenager who looked like me on screen. Watching Never Have I Ever encouraged me to live fully and loudly in my skin, and I hope it does the same for you too.
A year later in 2020, as I adjusted to online school and the many changes suddenly happening, I was happier than ever that Kaling’s project, now titled Never Have I Ever, was soon approaching and had just released a trailer. To my dismay, my enthusiasm waned as I watched the trailer. I thought the jokes were cringey, and was disappointed that the show did not seem to be the humorous and insightful commentary about being a brown teenager in America that I had hoped for.
After watching the whole series, I realized that the trailer is not a good representation of Never Have I Ever, but most importantly, I had unfair expectations for Kaling to begin with. She is one of the only mainstream female Indian-American producers in Hollywood, so I had unwittingly put increased pressure on her to sum up my entire cultural experience in one neat package with her new show. Everyone else in the Indian community wanted the same thing, though they all had different stories. This meant that Kaling had the burden of representing the entirety of the vast South Asian diaspora with her work, even though she should be allowed to tell whatever stories she wants to tell, shouldn’t she? In an interview with the New York Times, Kaling sums it up by saying,“[t]hose people who watch the show, particularly young Indian-American women, are the people that I want to like it the most. And they’re the ones that are going to be the toughest on me.”
This being said, as a “young Indian-American [woman]” myself, Never Have I Ever and its lead character Devi Vishwakumar (portrayed by Maitreyi Ramakrishnan) brought me joy. Devi is funny, bold, and unapologetic (sometimes to a fault). I was glad to see a realistic balance with how much Devi’s ethnicity informed her character. Devi’s race is neither blatantly ignored nor is it her sole defining trait. I would even argue that Devi’s experience as part of the Indian diaspora is not the most poignant part of the show, rather it is her experience with grief and trauma.
Devi, who is not shy but is nonetheless viewed as a “nerd” at school, is on a mission to reinvent herself in tenth grade. Though it is not uncommon to treat the new school year as a fresh start, Devi is fueled by the desire to return to equilibrium after catastrophe. Devi’s father died unexpectedly of a heart attack during her school orchestra concert the past year. As a psychosomatic response to this trauma, Devi became temporarily paralyzed and was confined to a wheelchair for the rest of her freshman year and summer, enduring taunts from insensitive classmates about her “fake” paralysis. Once Devi regains her ability to walk, which the show offers little explanation for, she is on a mission to move past loss by reinventing herself in the classic teen romcom fashion. She wears cute outfits, gets invited to parties with alcohol and (sort of) goes out with the most popular guy at school. Devi does all these things at the high cost of neglecting and eventually losing her best friends, but she still finds herself suffering from the unresolved trauma of her father’s death. Never Have I Ever takes the tropes of high school drama and uses them a vehicle to explore grief. However, the show’s serious subject matter did not bar it from being funny and light-hearted. The series is narrated by temperamental tennis legend John McEnroe, which seems like a strange choice but is eventually explained. Contrary to my expectations, McEnroe’s narration did not come off as condescending and I appreciated this unique element of the show.
Our protagonist, Devi, has a short fuse and wit which get her into sticky, albeit hilarious situations. My personal favorite is when she starts World War III at a Model United Nations conference to get back at her enemy, Ben Gross, portrayed by Jaren Lewison. I will admit that some of Devi’s questionable decisions made me cringe, but only because the show had roped me into caring about this realistically flawed, but fundamentally good character. Even though our stories are different, I felt emboldened seeing a chaotic, funny, and smart teenager who looked like me on screen. Watching Never Have I Ever encouraged me to live fully and loudly in my skin, and I hope it does the same for you too.
Comments
Post a Comment